Thursday, May 3, 2012
Computer User Interface trust.
I was creating a directory structure in Dolphin, so I typed in bar/bux/baz in the create folder dialog. I expected an error, or a path to be created. Instead, it converted "/" to a look alike, that I cannot simply type in the terminal. I feel violated.
https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=299086
Why is this such a violation?
I expect the computer to do what I tell it to do, and check for sanity. If it can't do what I asked it to do, I need it to ask me a question, or at least tell me what it plans to do.
Our computers should not take the names of files in Save-As dialog boxes. I have overwritten a file that took me hours to make because some ass hat decided to make a mouse-over take a filename, and the default action for the confirmation dialog box was yes. (we got that one fixed)
Files on removable media should not be put into trash automatically, This leaves the drive full, with no obvious way to clear it. Instead, something less than trash would be a good solution.
Queue to items to be deleted... and don't move the files to another folder until the queue is acted upon. This list should at least use tiemstamps, and the deletion program should check lsof to verify the file is safe to delete.
I understand that training and experience has a lot to do with what people expect computers. What are some things that we have been trained to do, that are a bit messed up?
Wednesday, May 2, 2012
mice and trackpads.
Single clicking can be done by accident very easily. Nothing dangerous should occur by a single click. Everything should be reversible. A double click should not perform an action twice.
hyperlinks, toolbar actions, and buttons are for revertible actions. A SUBMIT FORM FOR A WEBSITE SHOULD NOT BE A SINGLE CLICK
Buttons for hazardous actions should look differently than a safe action . Perhaps a color change should occur on the first click.
A hazardous action could be defined as anything that could cause data loss.
Running a program, opening a file, these are all hazardous.
Dangerous actions explicitly cause data loss.
Saving over a file is dangerous, (are you sure that is the right file?)
running an unauthenticated program is a dangerous action.
Deleting a file is a dangerous action.
(moving a file to trash could be classified as hazardous)
Taps frequently occur without the user knowing.
Tap-drags are pure evil.
I like how Microsoft has a default action of copy when dragging files between volumes. I like how they move by default when dragging within one volume.
I also like how Dolphin asks me what I want to do. but I don't like how it gets in my way.
I would like to have an informational dialog box show up, saying "move to" or "copy to" when I approach my target.
Holding down both buttons on a drag should cancel the drag.
Right click dragging should bring up the questionbox. (on drop)
(Yet another reason why Macintosh's are horrible)
hyperlinks, toolbar actions, and buttons are for revertible actions. A SUBMIT FORM FOR A WEBSITE SHOULD NOT BE A SINGLE CLICK
Buttons for hazardous actions should look differently than a safe action . Perhaps a color change should occur on the first click.
A hazardous action could be defined as anything that could cause data loss.
Running a program, opening a file, these are all hazardous.
Dangerous actions explicitly cause data loss.
Saving over a file is dangerous, (are you sure that is the right file?)
running an unauthenticated program is a dangerous action.
Deleting a file is a dangerous action.
(moving a file to trash could be classified as hazardous)
Taps frequently occur without the user knowing.
Tap-drags are pure evil.
I like how Microsoft has a default action of copy when dragging files between volumes. I like how they move by default when dragging within one volume.
I also like how Dolphin asks me what I want to do. but I don't like how it gets in my way.
I would like to have an informational dialog box show up, saying "move to" or "copy to" when I approach my target.
Holding down both buttons on a drag should cancel the drag.
Right click dragging should bring up the questionbox. (on drop)
(Yet another reason why Macintosh's are horrible)
internal representation of actions in the desktop and shell
When looking through the source code for KDE, I saw actions like on click.
I was looking for a way to solve the bug where the system settings panel uses the same settings as files. The system settings page is basically a web page, where single click is expected, but some idiot decided to punish people for setting double click as their preferred interaction method.
This got me thinking about how to represent interactions with the user, so that programmers are not confused by click.
This is also relevant for touch screens.
I would organize actions by how explicit/deliberate of a request they require., so that they could be adjusted by a system setting, and still
onpassiveInquery -- mouseover
oninquery -- righclick
onprobe -- single click
ondoacton --doubleclick
onexplicit action -- double click plus dialog or other interactive confirmation
ondangerousexplicit action -- require a captcha to be typed in
onsystempermission -- requrie sudo level... (this may still be separete.
This would allow us to design interfaces for multiple types of interaction, and swap the code for the interaction based on what type of device it is.
I was looking for a way to solve the bug where the system settings panel uses the same settings as files. The system settings page is basically a web page, where single click is expected, but some idiot decided to punish people for setting double click as their preferred interaction method.
This got me thinking about how to represent interactions with the user, so that programmers are not confused by click.
This is also relevant for touch screens.
I would organize actions by how explicit/deliberate of a request they require., so that they could be adjusted by a system setting, and still
onpassiveInquery -- mouseover
oninquery -- righclick
onprobe -- single click
ondoacton --doubleclick
onexplicit action -- double click plus dialog or other interactive confirmation
ondangerousexplicit action -- require a captcha to be typed in
onsystempermission -- requrie sudo level... (this may still be separete.
This would allow us to design interfaces for multiple types of interaction, and swap the code for the interaction based on what type of device it is.
Tuesday, May 1, 2012
Solution for yanking a liveusb drive out
Regarding Live Distros, Knoppix has a "to ram" option, where it copies the compressed file system to ram, and then the media can be removed.
I can't use that on my system because I only have 1gb ram.
Knoppix can create a swap file on a windows volume. (and use another system's swap partition) I don't want my users to mess up their windows disks. Yes, they can mount them and write to them, but I don't want accidents.
A solution would be to split the compressed filesystem into two parts. one that gets loaded into ram, and another that stays on the liveusb drive.
/bin
/root
/etc
(maybe a few of the core applications, like xwindows, and some sort of alert programs, and maybe cheat with a web browser in there so it loads quickly)
and then another with all the rest.
If the system volume gets yanked, a program should pause everything... like a pause for hibernation. Hopefully the programs will be able to deal with a minor glitch. If they can't it's a bug.
Then a nice big alert should show, REINSERT USB DRIVE TO BEGIN DATA RECONSTRUCTION, SYSTEM SUSPENDED, DATA IS LIKELY CORRUPTED
I can't use that on my system because I only have 1gb ram.
Knoppix can create a swap file on a windows volume. (and use another system's swap partition) I don't want my users to mess up their windows disks. Yes, they can mount them and write to them, but I don't want accidents.
A solution would be to split the compressed filesystem into two parts. one that gets loaded into ram, and another that stays on the liveusb drive.
/bin
/root
/etc
(maybe a few of the core applications, like xwindows, and some sort of alert programs, and maybe cheat with a web browser in there so it loads quickly)
and then another with all the rest.
If the system volume gets yanked, a program should pause everything... like a pause for hibernation. Hopefully the programs will be able to deal with a minor glitch. If they can't it's a bug.
Then a nice big alert should show, REINSERT USB DRIVE TO BEGIN DATA RECONSTRUCTION, SYSTEM SUSPENDED, DATA IS LIKELY CORRUPTED
Monday, April 30, 2012
The Sanity Shell
As part of the Cat Proof Computing Initiative, I want to have a shell that is extra rhobust, and will keep users safe from bad things, and becoming interactive at a certain point. I'm a bit pumped up from Linuxfest.
- I want to be safe from having files names -rf.
- I want parenthesis matching
- I want abnormal filename detection.
- colorized edit line. (all the text editors do it)
- interaction with the terminal so that an output that would display encoded characters does not leave the other applications that follow it in a strange character mode.
some of this danger could be mitigated with aliases.
some of this might require simulation.
*For the simulation*
I can conceive of situations where the action could not be simulated... say with self modifying code, or detection of the conditions like being on a different filesystem.
white listing actions could be interesting... but this isn't an easy problem to solve.
I just had a thought that I could use mount --bind to make a read only copy of my file system. I then could make a folder differences apparent by having unionfs overlay, then perform the actions and confirm that what happened was ok, then apply those changes.
I think this is a bit like having a transaction based shell... well we have transaction based filesystems, so that is likely the best way to deal with the idea... and reverting has less overhead.
*For shell and terminal interaction, I have seen terminals tell me what program is running inside it. It should be able to reset it's characters everytime the shell comes back. by paying attention to it's child processes.
Sunday, April 29, 2012
LFNW 2012 Custom Live USB Linux Presentation
Thank you to the attendees of my Linux Fest Northwest presentation!
I got through the material, but I'm sorry for the bits of disorganization. I feel I was below average, but still OK on quality, and hopefully scores better in usefulness.
I believe I now have 3 people trying my linux distro!
This Live USB project started as my Xmas Live Linux project.
This year, I made a Cat Proof Kubuntu Remix. I may need to change it's name to Giftable Linux.
iso for catproof is now availabile:
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B9eYzYpGeqzGWU4tUXRUQVdfUTg
other needed files are available at my website:
http://catproof.org
I got through the material, but I'm sorry for the bits of disorganization. I feel I was below average, but still OK on quality, and hopefully scores better in usefulness.
I believe I now have 3 people trying my linux distro!
This Live USB project started as my Xmas Live Linux project.
This year, I made a Cat Proof Kubuntu Remix. I may need to change it's name to Giftable Linux.
iso for catproof is now availabile:
https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B9eYzYpGeqzGWU4tUXRUQVdfUTg
other needed files are available at my website:
http://catproof.org
Tuesday, June 5, 2007
google doesn't recover accounts, laptop was stolen
Well, this may be my last post.
my laptop got stolen, and I changed my google password.
And I tried logging in again, and it didn't work.
So I'm just counting the days until my session expires, I'm screwed! They won't help me!
I'm going to loose all of the things that I use google for, and every other account that I have that is based on my gmail account.
I basically suffered a digital death!
(years later, I was able to gain access to my email that I used to create this account, and have it back again)
my laptop got stolen, and I changed my google password.
And I tried logging in again, and it didn't work.
So I'm just counting the days until my session expires, I'm screwed! They won't help me!
I'm going to loose all of the things that I use google for, and every other account that I have that is based on my gmail account.
I basically suffered a digital death!
(years later, I was able to gain access to my email that I used to create this account, and have it back again)
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)